In order to fund their escape from the mountains, Dutch has the gang rob the Cornwall train, which results in them getting a significant amount of money in bonds.

At some point in this chapter, Arthur can join Micah in robbing a stagecoach, bringing Bill along. As well as this, he can also rob a stagecoach with Lenny, although it proves to be a setup. Additionally, Arthur can also go rustling with Uncle.

Epilogue ” He did save us, yeah. None of us would be here today if it weren’t for Arthur.

Years after Arthur’s death, Mary is seen visiting his grave, weeping his loss, as well as a deer or a coyote, depending on his honor.

Arthur’s death is avenged after John, Sadie and Charles manage to track down Micah and his new crew at Mount Hagen. Micah eventually gets his comeuppance and is jointly killed by John and Dutch for betraying the gang and ratting it out to the Pinkertons. Ironically, John hunting down Micah and avenging Arthur’s death ultimately leads to Edgar Ross kidnapping his family and his own death four years later.

After the player has reached 100% completion, a short cut scene will play where John visits Arthur’s grave. John will be shown completing Arthur’s journal while uttering the words “Guess we’re just about done, my friend” before the cutscene transitions back to normal gameplay.